The Horror of the Homemade Halloween Costume

I was seven years old when I got my first big break.

 

“Okay, everyone line up along the back wall, shoulder to shoulder,” my second grade teacher instructed the class.

 

She made her way from student to student, slowly sizing each of us up. She claimed she was looking for the five tallest to act as lions in our upcoming school play but looking back I know the truth — she was looking for suckers.

 

“Mom! I get to be a lion in the school play!” I announced after school. “And the best part is that you get to make me a costume!” She eyed the McCalls pattern I held in my outstretched hand with the same regard as if I was handing her a bloody, severed head.

 

There was no way out for her, or any of the other moms who spent the next three days locked in their bedrooms with nothing but a sewing machine and a carton of Camels. Occasionally my dad would slide some food under the door, scared to get too close for the explicit language wafting in from the other side. I'd never heard anyone have such contempt for a zipper.

 

Finally, on Sunday night, she emerged victorious. A self-proclaimed martyr was born. Some moms guilt their kids with stories of a 30-hour labor, or perhaps a stomach bug that lasted for what seemed like years. To this day my mom still recounts the story of the weekend of the lion costume from hell.

 

After my successful theater debut I returned home and tossed the costume in the back of my closet.

 

“What on earth are you doing?” she shrieked, rushing over to pick it off the floor as if it was baby Jesus. “We're wearing this for Halloween! Let's not get it all wrinkled.”

 

What I didn't know was that by “wearing this for Halloween” she actually meant “wearing this for every Halloween until you die.” By the time I finally retired that thing the elastic ankles were just below my knees and there was more than one moment I feared the crotch section had permanently affixed itself to my cervix (one word — jumpsuit).

 

It is for this memory, among others which would come later in home economics, that I will never be the mom whose kids show up at doorsteps on Halloween eve as anything other than what you can buy in a bag. No – mine are the children sporting the “five-piece pirate suit” and answering the question of “What are you this year?” with “A medium.”

 

We kick off each Halloween season by driving to the nearest Wal-Mart costume aisle and I extend my arm as if I am presenting lost treasure and tell them to “pick one.”

 

And everyone's happy. The entire process takes roughly twenty minutes and zero guilt. My generic, store-bought costumed kids file in on Halloween night with other kids dressed up as tubes of toothpaste and bowls of spaghetti and sprinkled cupcakes happy as clams (also a cute costume idea if you're into that sort of thing).

 

My hat's off to any parent who chooses to tackle the homemade costume. Your kids are adorable and I'm sure they take pride in being original. But the mere thought of sitting before a sewing machine makes me clench areas still jumpy from the Little Wedgie that Could.

 

Feeling somewhat nostalgic this week, I emailed my childhood friend and fellow second grade circus co-star to ask if she had any pictures of us in costume from that night. Apparently my mom has since destroyed any photographic evidence from that experience in an effort of self-preservation.

 

“Oh it's interesting you're asking me about that now,” she replied. “I just bought our costume supplies to make an English rider and a piece of bubble gum!”

 

I guess it's true that we all process trauma in different ways. Or maybe her mom just had a less colorful vocabulary.

 

Share This Story

Hannah Mayer is a nationally award-winning blogger, humor columnist and exponentially blessed wife and mother of three. She would trade everything for twelve uninterrupted hours in a room with Jon Hamm and two Ambien. You can find her on Facebook, Instagram or at her blog, sKIDmarks.

Our Daily Things to Do email is the easiest way to plan your day.
Follow Us
 
Things to Do

Garden Glow at the Missouri Botanical Garden
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Monday, November 23, 2026

More than a million lights will illuminate some of the Missouri Botanical Garden's most iconic locations, walkways will be transformed into sensory light tunnels providing an explosion of visual magic, and traditional candlelight village displays, festive drinks, s'mores and great photo opportunities will delight crowds of all ages.

 

 

View this event »
Brewery Lights at Anheuser-Busch Brewery
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Friday, November 27, 2026

Enjoy the iconic lights that adorn the Anheuser-Busch Brewery close up during walking tours. Brewery Lights features more than one million twinkling lights, a Kids Winter Wonderland, a nightly holiday parade featuring the World-Famous Clydesdales, and lots of family-friendly activities. 

View this event »
Breakfast with Santa at Eckerts
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Saturday, November 28, 2026

At Breakfast with Santa at Eckerts, your child can tell Santa their Christmas wishes, have their photo taken with him and decorate some holiday cookies while your whole family enjoys a farm-fresh breakfast. 

View this event »
Family Sunday at the Saint Louis Art Museum
Sunday, November 22, 2026

Families are invited to the Saint Louis Art Museum on Sunday afternoon to participate in free hands-on art activities with fun themes and to explore the galleries. Each Family Sunday focuses on a different family-friendly theme. 

View this event »
Want daily ideas of things to do? How about special offers & giveaways? Sign up and we’ll handle the rest.
Popular Stories

How Today's Summer Camps Are Meeting the Needs of a New Generation

Ask parents what they remember about summer camp, and they'll typically mention things like swimming until their fingers were wrinkled, making lopsided crafts, singing around a campfire, and making new friends. Camp was a chance to get outside, try something new, and enjoy a bit of freedom.

Children today still have some of those experiences. But summer camp looks and functions a bit differently today, since camps must adapt to a very different childhood than parents remember. Here are some examples of some of the changes:

Continue reading »
Dinoroarus Comes Roaring Back at the Saint Louis Zoo

The Dinoroarus exhibit brings prehistoric fun back to the Saint Louis Zoo this summer with 20 lifelike dinosaur animatronics and sculptures on the Zoo's Historic Hill.

Continue reading »
Winter Getaway Returns to the Missouri History Museum This Holiday Season

One of the most popular holiday experiences for children in St. Louis doesn’t cost a single cent. Winter Getaway at the Missouri History Museum is packed with free kid-friendly activities, musical performances, arts and crafts, and workshops that celebrate our city’s rich culture and holiday heritage.

Continue reading »
City Museum's Stuff the Bus Campaign Provides School Supplies for 160 St. Louis Schools

Visit City Museum August 3-31, bring school supplies to donate, and get discounted admission! That's the idea behind City Museum's Stuff the Bus campaign.

Continue reading »
You Might Also Like...

From Our Sponsors
Follow Us