Is Submission the New "S" Word?

The other day I was surfing through a nationally-recognized blog I read for its train wreck value rather than its inspirational insights and came across a post declaring the author’s “submission” to her husband.

That’s when I started waving my pointer finger at the monitor and bellowed,  “Oh no you did not!” (Seriously, I just can’t pull off sassy).

Although I’m not one to bash someone’s personal philosophy on his or her own blog, that didn’t stop me from immediately emailing my friend who also follows said blogger. My friend is about as “I am woman, hear me roar” as they come. Master’s degree, three smart kids, full-time job –  the feminist movement personified.

Me: Did you read this?

Her: Yes? And?

Me: She’s telling readers to submit to their husbands!

Her: It’s not some S&M thing. She’s just saying someone has to fly the plane.

Me: That’s B.S. Marriage is a partnership. Even Captain Sully had a co-pilot.

Her: True. But Captain Sully actually landed the plane.

As someone who considers herself a soft-core women’s libber – one who brings home the bacon and fries it up in the pan without her armpit-and-leg hair getting in the way – the word “submission” stirs up negative connotations of a woman sacrificing her beliefs and goals to further those of her husband. Betty Draper, if you will, who sits unfulfilled on the sidelines while philandering Don rules the roost until her frustration eventually erupts.

Right now, this working mom who also happens to be a Christian, often feels stuck between my feminist counterparts who tell me I don’t need to depend on no stinkin’ man and more traditional folks who tell me my marriage would be stronger if I stopped emasculating the husband with all my womanly question askin’.

This area got even muddier when reports surfaced that Michele Bachmann – an intelligent, accomplished presidential candidate – stated that according to the Bible, women are to be submissive to their husbands. While Bachmann explained her statement in 2011 by remarking, “What submission means to us, it means respect. I respect my husband. He’s a wonderful godly man and great father,” it’s still extremely hard for me to comprehend submission = respect.

The conservative view

For some clarification from the other side of the spectrum, I turned to Suzanne Venker, coauthor of The Flipside of Feminism and author of 7 Myths of Working Mothers to get a conservative’s insight on what submission means to her.

“I understand why the word submission sounds scary to many people – feminists have butchered the term,” she remarked via email. “Being submissive in a marriage (something I'm not naturally good at, by the way – not because I think the word's demeaning but because I'm a strong-willed person) means not always having to have the upper hand in a situation or be right all the time. It means allowing oneself to be vulnerable and letting someone else drive the boat once in a while. It means, in effect, to surrender one's power when having power isn't necessary.”

“The term submission is often equated with the word subservience because that's what feminists teach. But the two are entirely different. Subservience means being ‘beneath’ a person, or one person having less value than the other. In fact I would go so far as to say that if anyone's subservient in marriage today, it's the husband.”

Venker said she does consider marriage a partnership and is not arguing for the return to strict gender roles when it comes to running a household. However, a relationship built on a 50/50 concept, according to her, can’t work since it “dismisses the fact that men are better at some things and women are better at others” and is really just a logistical nightmare when two people who can’t agree each try to direct the traffic.

“The greatest problem with rejecting the idea of being submissive, or surrendering, is that you set your relationship up as a competitive one rather than a complementary one. Women (and men!) have been sold a bill of goods with the absurd notion that women should be independent at all costs, lest they ‘lose’ themselves in marriage. That is the premise of the feminist message.”

For me, marriage will, in my eyes, always be a 50/50 relationship – sometimes the husband takes the lead; sometimes I do. I respect Mr. P, but I will darn well challenge him if his decisions aren’t in align with the goals of our family. And believe me, that philosophy swings both ways.

So, what is your stance on marriage “submission?” And please be kind to one another here. If there's anything feminism should have taught us is that it’s important to value our fellow sisters’ philosophies.

By Nicole Plegge, Lifestyle Blogger for SmartParenting

Share This Story

Metro East mom Nicole Plegge has written for STL Parent for more than 12 years. Besides working as a freelance writer & public relations specialist, and raising two daughters and a husband, Nicole's greatest achievements are finding her misplaced car keys each day and managing to leave the house in a stain-free shirt. Her biggest regret is never being accepted to the Eastland School for Girls. Follow Nicole on Twitter @STLWriterinIL 

Our Daily Things to Do email is the easiest way to plan your day.
Follow Us
 
Want daily ideas of things to do? How about special offers & giveaways? Sign up and we’ll handle the rest.
Things to Do

Family Night With Fredbird
Wednesday, November 13, 2024
Wednesday, December 11, 2024
Wednesday, January 15, 2025

Bring your family to Cardinals Nation Restaurant on select Wednesday nights for Family Night with Fredbird! Meet Fredbird from 6:30-7:30 p.m., play games and win prizes! Kids 12 and under eat free per adult meal purchased.

View this event »
Music & Movement

Explore songs, finger plays, music and more during this Music & Movement class for ages 0-6. Some sessions are held in person at various branches of the St. Louis County Library. Some sessions are virtual. 

 

 

View this event »
You Might Also Like...

From Our Sponsors
Popular Stories

Embark on an Adventure at SLSO's Concert for Kids: Wild Symphony!

Embark on a musical adventure with Dan Brown’s latest surprise, Wild Symphony! Travel through the trees and across the seas to meet a wonderous whale and impatient ponies, busy beetles, and an eager elephant—each with a special secret to share. 

Continue reading »
COCA Ignites Creativity and Sparks Fun for Kids of All Ages, All Summer Long

Stroll along the Walk of Fame in the Delmar Loop, and you’ll spot the playwrights, actors, and artists who got their start in St. Louis, from Tennessee Williams and Katherine Dunham, to Tina Turner and John Goodman. Just a few steps away and around the corner, a new generation of Gateway City superstars will discover their love for the visual and performing arts this summer.

Continue reading »
Farmer's Markets Make Great Family Outings! Here is Your 2024 Guide to Farmers Markets Across the St. Louis Area

A trip to the farmer’s market is a fun outing for the entire family – and it can be educational too. Make plans to visit one (or several) of these top St. Louis farmers’ markets this spring and summer, so that you and your kids can learn more about where your food comes from and indulge in some of the freshest, seasonal produce the St. Louis region has to offer. Plus, many of these markets offer activities just for kids, feature food trucks, welcome dogs, and more.    

Continue reading »
6 Places to Find Fun on the Farm this Fall

Visiting a farm can be a real adventure for city and suburban kids. Getting up close to and even feeding farm animals can lead to lots of fun and unexpected learning. We've rounded up some tried and true nearby options where your family can spend a day in the country and meet some new barnyard friends.

Continue reading »
SUE: The T. Rex Experience to Roar Into the Saint Louis Science Center

This summer. families can meet Sue, the most complete, best-preserved Tyrannosaurus rex ever found, in the Lou! The Saint Louis Science Center will welcome SUE: The T. rex Experience beginning June 8. The special exhibition features the latest scientific discoveries about the species as a whole along as well immersive, sensory exploration of life in the Cretaceous period.

Continue reading »
Follow Us